It's all about the chili
This chili sauce is the best!
We have been here several times and the chili sauce is delicious.
The Dogs are the Best and the Chili on them makes them even better.
Gear Up In The Shop!
M+P Coney Island Flavor
"With Everything", since 1923
Our famous chili sauce, strong onions, and yellow mustard... you can't beat our "with everything" dog.
M+P Coney Island was started in New Castle in 1923 by 2 Greek immigrants: John Mitsos and George Papazekos, hence the "M+P".
John Mitsos was a fixture at Coney's for nearly 60 years, until he passed away in 2014. His children have taken over ownership of the business keeping the M+P legacy safe.
Locations
2712 Wilmington Rd,
New Castle, PA
9 East Washington Street,
New Castle, PA